By Coptic Solidarity –
Egypt’s Cairo Criminal Court (Terrorism Circuit) has renewed the pretrial detention of Coptic taxi driver and social media commentator Romany Gharib Adly Azer for another 45 days, without him even appearing before a judge.
According to Egyptian media reports, the court ordered on November 14, 2026 Gharib’s continued detention pending investigations in Supreme State Security Case No. 4832/2026, in which he faces accusations of “joining a terrorist group” and “spreading false news.”
Some news outlets reported that the detention was renewed despite Gharib’s absence from the hearing because a videoconference connection between the court and the prison could not be established.
Apparently, the failure of the authorities’ own communication system was not considered an obstacle to depriving a citizen of his liberty for another 45 days.
The decision also marks a new stage in Gharib’s detention. Until recently, the Supreme State Security Prosecution had been renewing his detention for successive 15-day periods. Responsibility for reviewing his continued detention has now passed to the Criminal Court, where renewals can be ordered for 45 days at a time.
From Reporting Police Misconduct to Facing Terrorism Charges
As previously reported by Coptic Solidarity, Gharib’s ordeal began on June 18, when he declined a police officer’s demand at Cairo International Airport to transport an individual in his vehicle.
According to Gharib, the officer retaliated by confiscating his identification card, driving license and route permit, effectively preventing him from carrying out his professional duties at the airport.
Gharib subsequently posted a video on Facebook recounting the incident and appealing to officials to intervene. Two days later, he was arrested in Suez and, according to the Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms (ECRF), subjected to enforced disappearance before appearing before the Supreme State Security Prosecution.
Rather than investigating his allegations of police misconduct, the authorities treated the complainant himself as a national security threat.
Even more absurdly, investigators cited an earlier satirical Facebook post in which Gharib appeared riding a donkey, joking that it would become his future means of transportation following government increases in gasoline prices.
His lawyers have repeatedly challenged the legal basis of the accusations, emphasizing that neither his complaint against the police officer nor his satirical criticism of government policies constitutes criminal conduct, let alone terrorism.
In October, ECRF called for Gharib’s immediate release, an investigation into his original complaint, and accountability for those responsible for his alleged arbitrary arrest and enforced disappearance.
Yet, as some Egyptian news outlets noted, no investigation into his complaint against the police officer has been publicly announced.
Detention as Punishment, Judicial Review as a Formality
The latest decision exposes two increasingly troubling features of Egypt’s justice system: the abusive use of counterterrorism legislation to suppress peaceful expression and the transformation of pretrial detention into a punishment in its own right.
Judicial review of detention is supposed to protect citizens against arbitrary deprivation of liberty, not merely provide procedural cover for its continuation.
Article 54 of Egypt’s Constitution guarantees personal liberty and establishes safeguards against arbitrary detention. Article 9 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, to which Egypt is a party, guarantees the right to challenge the lawfulness of detention before a court.
What meaningful judicial protection remains when a court can order another 45 days of imprisonment without even hearing the individual whose liberty is at stake?
Beyond Gharib’s personal ordeal, the case sends an intimidating message to ordinary Egyptians: complaining about police misconduct, appealing to public officials for redress, or even joking about rising prices can expose a citizen to prolonged imprisonment under terrorism-related accusations.
Coptic Solidarity reiterates its call for the immediate and unconditional release of Romany Gharib Adly Azer, an independent investigation into his allegations of police misconduct, and an end to the abusive use of counterterrorism legislation and prolonged pretrial detention to punish peaceful expression.
The authorities should be investigating the alleged abuse of power, not imprisoning the citizen who dared to report it.
